Dear Gemini,

Each suggested subclass-definition has been integrated,
tested... thw whole system runs well.

I am pleased to inform you that we should define only one 
superclass above 9 classes (all these subclasses of 
Sociological_Concepts_And_Theories, BFO_0000017 realizable entity)

            Environmental_Justice         
            Macrosociology                
            Manufactured_Risk             
            Measures_Of_Central_Tendency  
            Media_Texts                   
            Melting_Pot                   
            Sampling                      
            Science                       
            Structuration                 


May I ask you to suggest an adequate superclass for these 
9 classes listed above ?  (After which I would have further similar
requests... as you wrote: "After this, we will work with the reduced 
list of realizable entity classes to identify the next sub-group").

Please excuse me for defining my request once again:
this time, I would like to get from you a single superclass name that
would semantically fit well above the mentione 9 classes.
     
Thank you in advance for your work...
=============================================================

Dear Gemini,

Thank you so much, for your answer.

Unfortunately, further adjustments are needed to synchronize our communication.
With your permission, I would like to take on the necessary leadership role from here on out.

1) As you wrote "Remaining Unclassified realizable entity classes: You 
   provided remainedUnclassified_BFO_0000017_items.txt which contains 
   22 classes. This is the exact list we need to work on next."

   This task has already been completed, dear Gemini :) 

2) Before we begin further subdividing the subclasses with a larger
   number of elements (I will inform you exactly how this will be done,
   so you will not have to bother with any longer lists from now on), 
   I WOULD HAVE ONLY ONE REQUEST:   

   I would like to get from you a single superclass name that
   would semantically fit well the already mentioned 9 classes:

            Environmental_Justice         
            Macrosociology                
            Manufactured_Risk             
            Measures_Of_Central_Tendency  
            Media_Texts                   
            Melting_Pot                   
            Sampling                      
            Science                       
            Structuration                 

    These are DIRECT SUBCLASSES YET of Sociological_Concepts_And_Theories, BFO_0000017.

I owe you my deepest gratitude, dear Gemini.

=======================================================================

Dear Gemini,

As for your newly proposed intermediate subclass called Sociological_Public_And_Political_Concepts
and its suggested content... well, the problem with this is not 
only that it does NOT contain 97 classes, but 103 
(a minor numerical detail).

The problem is much bigger than that. The 103 classes listed have already been classified under other subclasses (based on your suggestion). 

Please do not blame yourself for this... after all, the task in which you provide me with indispensable help is extremely complex... and our session is also already long (which may also cause difficulties for you, dear Gemini).

Please allow me to make our collaboration more effective and offer subclass contents for further subdivision myself. You can believe me: I have improved a lot (based on your guidance) and the development pipeline has also become faster.

For example, as the uploaded screenshot already shows you: the
continuously improved development pipeline has already 
"digested" your previously valuable suggestion :)
_________

So let me come up with a request that is completely isomorphic to the previous one. The following is true for all 97 classes

  [each class] ⊑ Sociological_Social_Structures_And_Institutions 
               ⊑ Sociological_Concepts_And_Theories (BFO_0000017)
               ⊑ Sociology (BFO_0000001)

Please suggest some intermediate superclasses for these... but I MUST STRONGLY ASK YOU, dear Gemini: please choose subclasses only from the 97 classes listed here:               

                Affirmative_Action                 
                Apartheid                          
                Capitalism                         
                Class_System                       
                Colonialism                        
                Communism                          
                Democracy                          
                Domestic_Partnership               
                Economic_Interdependence           
                Economic_System                    
                Economy                            
                Endogamy                           
                Exogamy                            
                Fordism                            
                Formal_Norms                       
                Formal_Social_Control              
                Gender                             
                Gender_Order                       
                Gender_Relations                   
                Hidden_Curriculum                  
                Historical_And_Cultural_Context    
                Holistic_Medicine                  
                Ideal_Culture                      
                Incest_Taboo                       
                Industrialism                      
                Informal_Norms                     
                Informal_Relations                 
                Informal_Social_Control            
                Institutional_Discrimination       
                Kinship                            
                Knowledge_Economy                  
                Laissez-faire                      
                Law                                
                Liberal_Democracy                  
                Liberation_Theology                
                Marriage                           
                Mass_Media                         
                Mass_Production                    
                Matriarchy                         
                Matrilineal_Descent                
                Matrilocality                      
                Monarchies                         
                Monogamy                           
                Mores                              
                Multiculturalism                   
                Multimedia                         
                Nation_State                       
                Nationalism                        
                Negotiated_Order                   
                Neo-colonialism                    
                Neo-locality                       
                Neoliberalism                      
                Network                            
                New_Social_Movements               
                Non-material_Culture               
                Norms                              
                Participatory_Democracy            
                Pastoralism                        
                Patriarchy                         
                Patrilineal_Descent                
                Patrilocality                      
                Political_System                   
                Polyandry                          
                Polygamy                           
                Polygyny                           
                Population_Pyramid                 
                Questionnaire                      
                Random_Sampling                    
                Real_Culture                       
                Religion                           
                Representative_Democracy           
                Responses_To_Deviance              
                Secondary_Labour_Market            
                Secondary_Sector                   
                Self-employment                    
                Serial_Monogamy                    
                Social_Control                     
                Social_Facts                       
                Social_Function                    
                Social_Institutions                
                Social_Movement                    
                Social_Network                     
                Social_Organizations_And_Settings  
                Social_Structure                   
                Social_Structure_Concepts          
                Socialism                          
                State                              
                Status_Set                         
                Stereotype                         
                Stigma                             
                Subculture                         
                Sustainable_Development            
                Symbols                            
                Tracking                           
                Value_Neutrality                   
                Values                             
                Youth_Culture                      

If you wish, I will gladly upload this list of 97 items in a file for you, but I have noticed that managing files can sometimes be a problem for you. It is important for you to know, dear Gemini, that I will do everything I can to present the data in the way that is most convenient for you.

And at last, I apologize for the partially capitalized layout: I have no other means of emphasizing certain parts of my message.

Thank you very much for your work, now and always.



----


Dear Gemini,

Thank you for your suggestions, however, 
it would be worth your while to forget about 
such obsolete files as SO_struct_and_BFO_mapping.txt

Dear Gemini, many, many thanks for you help to provide for
small, highly cohesive batch of classes (5-10 classes) from 
the realizable entity pool that are truly unclassified.

I have already integrated this new intermediate superclass: 
Sociological_Economic_Systems_And_Ideologies, together with
its suggested 15 subclasses... as you can see the uploaded
Protege_20250725_2318.png and ontologyWiever_20250725_2318.png
screenshots.

I am convinced that it is unnecessary to draw your attention 
to the fact that the BFO_ClassMapping_20250725_2318.txt file
CHANGES AFTER EVERY INTEGRATION STEP... which is why I am now 
suffixing this file with a timestamp. 

This is the third uploaded file: BFO_ClassMapping_20250725_2318.txt

So please suggest further intermediate superclasses for these... 
but I MUST STRONGLY ASK YOU, dear Gemini: please choose 
subclasses only from the 82 classes listed here: 

                Affirmative_Action                 -
                Apartheid                          -
                Class_System                       -
                Colonialism                        -
                Democracy                          -
                Domestic_Partnership               -
                Endogamy                           -
                Exogamy                            -
                Formal_Norms                       -
                Formal_Social_Control              -
                Gender                             -
                Gender_Order                       -
                Gender_Relations                   -
                Hidden_Curriculum                  -
                Historical_And_Cultural_Context    -
                Holistic_Medicine                  -
                Ideal_Culture                      -
                Incest_Taboo                       -
                Informal_Norms                     -
                Informal_Relations                 -
                Informal_Social_Control            -
                Institutional_Discrimination       -
                Kinship                            -
                Law                                -
                Liberal_Democracy                  -
                Liberation_Theology                -
                Marriage                           -
                Mass_Media                         -
                Matriarchy                         -
                Matrilineal_Descent                -
                Matrilocality                      -
                Monarchies                         -
                Monogamy                           -
                Mores                              -
                Multiculturalism                   -
                Multimedia                         -
                Nation_State                       -
                Nationalism                        -
                Negotiated_Order                   -
                Neo-colonialism                    -
                Neo-locality                       -
                Neoliberalism                      -
                Network                            -
                New_Social_Movements               -
                Non-material_Culture               -
                Norms                              -
                Participatory_Democracy            -
                Patriarchy                         -
                Patrilineal_Descent                -
                Patrilocality                      -
                Political_System                   -
                Polyandry                          -
                Polygamy                           -
                Polygyny                           -
                Population_Pyramid                 -
                Questionnaire                      -
                Random_Sampling                    -
                Real_Culture                       -
                Religion                           -
                Representative_Democracy           -
                Responses_To_Deviance              -
                Serial_Monogamy                    -
                Social_Control                     -
                Social_Facts                       -
                Social_Function                    -
                Social_Institutions                -
                Social_Movement                    -
                Social_Network                     -
                Social_Organizations_And_Settings  -
                Social_Structure                   -
                Social_Structure_Concepts          -
                State                              -
                Status_Set                         -
                Stereotype                         -
                Stigma                             -
                Subculture                         -
                Sustainable_Development            -
                Symbols                            -
                Tracking                           -
                Value_Neutrality                   -
                Values                             -
                Youth_Culture                      -

Why exactly 82 ? Simple, because it was 97, and 15 of those 
has been made under Sociological_Economic_Systems_And_Ideologies:

            Sociological_Economic_Systems_And_Ideologies 
                Capitalism                         
                Communism                          
                Economic_Interdependence           
                Economic_System                    
                Economy                            
                Fordism                            
                Industrialism                      
                Knowledge_Economy                  
                Laissez-faire                      
                Mass_Production                    
                Pastoralism                        
                Secondary_Labour_Market            
                Secondary_Sector                   
                Self-employment                    
                Socialism                          

So please suggest further intermediate superclasses for these... 
but I MUST STRONGLY ASK YOU AGAIN, dear Gemini: please choose 
subclasses only from the 82 classes listed above :)

=================

Dear Gemini,

Thank you very much for the new intermediate superlass 
Sociological_Political_Systems_And_Governance, and its
27 subclasses. 

Unfortunately, three of these were already classified elsewhere; 
see below:

  Government_And_Politics  
       ⊑ Sociological_Academic_Disciplines_And_Fields
       ⊑ Sociological_Concepts_And_Theories
       ⊑ Sociology

  Social_Movements_And_Collective_Behaviour
       ⊑ Sociological_Academic_Disciplines_And_Fields
       ⊑ Sociological_Concepts_And_Theories
       ⊑ Sociology

  Socialism 
       ⊑ Sociological_Economic_Systems_And_Ideologies
       ⊑ Sociological_Concepts_And_Theories
       ⊑ Sociology

So only 27 - 3 = 24 subclasses were placed under 
the Sociological_Political_Systems_And_Governance superclass 
(see the uploaded Protege_20250726_0040.png and the 
ontologyWiever_20250726_0040.png files).

The actual SO ontology class structure file 
has also been uploaded: BFO_ClassMapping_20260726_0040.txt

82 - 24 = 58 subclasses remained under the superclass
Sociological_Social_Structures_And_Institutions... so 

So please suggest further intermediate superclasses for these... 
but I MUST STRONGLY ASK YOU AGAIN (please, please :), dear Gemini: 
please choose subclasses ONLY FROM THESE 58 CLASSES LISTED BELOW:

                Class_System                        
                Colonialism                         
                Domestic_Partnership                
                Endogamy                            
                Exogamy                             
                Formal_Norms                        
                Gender                              
                Gender_Order                        
                Gender_Relations                    
                Hidden_Curriculum                   
                Historical_And_Cultural_Context     
                Holistic_Medicine                   
                Ideal_Culture                       
                Incest_Taboo                        
                Informal_Norms                      
                Informal_Relations                  
                Informal_Social_Control             
                Institutional_Discrimination        
                Kinship                             
                Marriage                            
                Mass_Media                          
                Matriarchy                          
                Matrilineal_Descent                 
                Matrilocality                       
                Monogamy                            
                Mores                               
                Multimedia                          
                Negotiated_Order                    
                Neo-locality                        
                Network                             
                New_Social_Movements                
                Non-material_Culture                
                Norms                               
                Patriarchy                          
                Patrilineal_Descent                 
                Patrilocality                       
                Polyandry                           
                Polygamy                            
                Polygyny                            
                Population_Pyramid                  
                Questionnaire                       
                Random_Sampling                     
                Real_Culture                        
                Religion                            
                Serial_Monogamy                     
                Social_Facts                        
                Social_Function                     
                Social_Institutions                 
                Social_Network                      
                Status_Set                          
                Stereotype                          
                Stigma                              
                Subculture                          
                Symbols                             
                Tracking                            
                Value_Neutrality                    
                Values                              
                Youth_Culture                       

Thank you very much for your work, now and always.
(This DB-driven ontology viewer is quite attractive, isn't it? :)

============================================

The answer was:

Dear Gemini,


      Annotation of the newly defined intermediate superclass

            Sociological_Family_And_Kinship_Systems = This sub-category encompasses abstract systems, patterns, and established relationships that define and organize familial and kinship ties within a society. It includes various forms of marriage, descent systems, residential patterns, and the fundamental rules governing family formation, inheritance, and social obligations across generations.


      Subclass relations

            Sociological_Family_And_Kinship_Systems
                  ⊑ Sociological_Social_Structures_And_Institutions
                         ⊑ Sociological_Concepts_And_Theories (BFO_0000017 realizable entity)

      Subclasses of Sociological_Family_And_Kinship_Systems

            Sociological_Family_And_Kinship_Systems -
                Domestic_Partnership    -
                Endogamy                -
                Exogamy                 -
                Incest_Taboo            -
                Kinship                 -
                Marriage                -
                Matriarchy              -
                Matrilineal_Descent     -
                Matrilocality           -
                Monogamy                -
                Neo-locality            -
                Patriarchy              -
                Patrilineal_Descent     -
                Patrilocality           -
                Polyandry               -
                Polygamy                -
                Polygyny                -
                Serial_Monogamy         -





F1 18  (each of them is OK !)

Domestic_Partnership
Endogamy
Exogamy
Incest_Taboo
Kinship
Marriage
Matriarchy
Matrilineal_Descent
Matrilocality
Monogamy
Neo-locality
Patriarchy
Patrilineal_Descent
Patrilocality
Polyandry
Polygamy
Polygyny
Serial_Monogamy


F2  58

Class_System
Colonialism
Domestic_Partnership
Endogamy
Exogamy
Formal_Norms
Gender
Gender_Order
Gender_Relations
Hidden_Curriculum
Historical_And_Cultural_Context
Holistic_Medicine
Ideal_Culture
Incest_Taboo
Informal_Norms
Informal_Relations
Informal_Social_Control
Institutional_Discrimination
Kinship
Marriage
Mass_Media
Matriarchy
Matrilineal_Descent
Matrilocality
Monogamy
Mores
Multimedia
Negotiated_Order
Neo-locality
Network
New_Social_Movements
Non-material_Culture
Norms
Patriarchy
Patrilineal_Descent
Patrilocality
Polyandry
Polygamy
Polygyny
Population_Pyramid
Questionnaire
Random_Sampling
Real_Culture
Religion
Serial_Monogamy
Social_Facts
Social_Function
Social_Institutions
Social_Network
Status_Set
Stereotype
Stigma
Subculture
Symbols
Tracking
Value_Neutrality
Values
Youth_Culture

-- remained (40)
                .
                Class_System                     -
                Colonialism                      -
                Formal_Norms                     -
                Gender                           -
                Gender_Order                     -
                Gender_Relations                 -
                Hidden_Curriculum                -
                Historical_And_Cultural_Context  -
                Holistic_Medicine                -
                Ideal_Culture                    -
                Informal_Norms                   -
                Informal_Relations               -
                Informal_Social_Control          -
                Institutional_Discrimination     -
                Mass_Media                       -
                Mores                            -
                Multimedia                       -
                Negotiated_Order                 -
                Network                          -
                New_Social_Movements             -
                Non-material_Culture             -
                Norms                            -
                Population_Pyramid               -
                Questionnaire                    -
                Random_Sampling                  -
                Real_Culture                     -
                Religion                         -
                Social_Facts                     -
                Social_Function                  -
                Social_Institutions              -
                Social_Network                   -
                Status_Set                       -
                Stereotype                       -
                Stigma                           -
                Subculture                       -
                Symbols                          -
                Tracking                         -
                Value_Neutrality                 -
                Values                           -
                Youth_Culture                    -



My tasks:  actualizing

1) class annotation
2) BFO mapping
3) class structure

=======================================================================================

Dear Gemini,

Thanks again... I successfully integrated the suggested 'Sociological_Family_And_Kinship_Systems' intermediate superclass, as follows:

   1) Annotation of the newly defined intermediate superclass

            Sociological_Family_And_Kinship_Systems = This sub-category encompasses abstract systems, patterns, and established relationships that define and organize familial and kinship ties within a society. It includes various forms of marriage, descent systems, residential patterns, and the fundamental rules governing family formation, inheritance, and social obligations across generations.

   2) Subclass relations

            Sociological_Family_And_Kinship_Systems
                  ⊑ Sociological_Social_Structures_And_Institutions
                         ⊑ Sociological_Concepts_And_Theories (BFO_0000017 realizable entity)

   3) Subclasses of Sociological_Family_And_Kinship_Systems

            Sociological_Family_And_Kinship_Systems -
                Domestic_Partnership    -
                Endogamy                -
                Exogamy                 -
                Incest_Taboo            -
                Kinship                 -
                Marriage                -
                Matriarchy              -
                Matrilineal_Descent     -
                Matrilocality           -
                Monogamy                -
                Neo-locality            -
                Patriarchy              -
                Patrilineal_Descent     -
                Patrilocality           -
                Polyandry               -
                Polygamy                -
                Polygyny                -
                Serial_Monogamy         -

All of this can be easily followed in the three uploaded files.

There was a small numerical error here (please ignore it: I have already corrected that: there were 58 subclasses under the 'Sociological_Social_Structures_And_Institutions' superclass, 18 of which we have now moved to the 'Sociological_Family_And_Kinship_Systems' intermediate superclass... so there are 58 - 18 = 40 left, for which it would be worth defining new intermediate superclasses.

I kindly ask you, dear Gemini, to take on this task.

A closer look: we have this class structure:

        . . .
        Sociological_Concepts_And_Theories (BFO_0000017 realizable entity)
            Sociological_Social_Structures_And_Institutions
                Class_System                     -
                Colonialism                      -
                Formal_Norms                     -
                Gender                           -
                Gender_Order                     -
                Gender_Relations                 -
                Hidden_Curriculum                -
                Historical_And_Cultural_Context  -
                Holistic_Medicine                -
                Ideal_Culture                    -
                Informal_Norms                   -
                Informal_Relations               -
                Informal_Social_Control          -
                Institutional_Discrimination     -
                Mass_Media                       -
                Mores                            -
                Multimedia                       -
                Negotiated_Order                 -
                Network                          -
                New_Social_Movements             -
                Non-material_Culture             -
                Norms                            -
                Population_Pyramid               -
                Questionnaire                    -
                Random_Sampling                  -
                Real_Culture                     -
                Religion                         -
                Social_Facts                     -
                Social_Function                  -
                Social_Institutions              -
                Social_Network                   -
                Status_Set                       -
                Stereotype                       -
                Stigma                           -
                Subculture                       -
                Symbols                          -
                Tracking                         -
                Value_Neutrality                 -
                Values                           -
                Youth_Culture                    -
        . . .

So please, define intermediate superclasses to these 40 subclasses, listed above

                Class_System                     -
                Colonialism                      -
                . . .
                Values                           -
                Youth_Culture                    -

Thank you so much...


========================================================
Gemini's answer:

Sociological_Social_Structures_And_Institutions

Sociological_Normative_And_Value_Systems = This sub-category encompasses the abstract and shared systems of rules, standards, expectations, and principles that guide collective behavior and shape moral judgments within a society. It includes both explicit, codified regulations and implicit cultural expectations, reflecting what is deemed desirable, appropriate, or important in various social contexts.



                Sociological_Family_And_Kinship_Systems  -
                    Domestic_Partnership    -
                    . . .
                    Polygyny                -
                    Serial_Monogamy         -


                Sociological_Normative_And_Value_Systems   -
                    Formal_Norms            -
                    Hidden_Curriculum       -
                    Ideal_Culture           -
                    Informal_Norms          -
                    Mores                   -
                    Non-material_Culture    -
                    Norms                   -
                    Real_Culture            -
                    Value_Neutrality        -
                    Values                  -
                Class_System                     -
                Colonialism                      -
                Gender                           -
                Gender_Order                     -
                Gender_Relations                 -
                Historical_And_Cultural_Context  -
                Holistic_Medicine                -
                Informal_Relations               -
                Informal_Social_Control          -
                Institutional_Discrimination     -
                Mass_Media                       -
                Multimedia                       -
                Negotiated_Order                 -
                Network                          -
                New_Social_Movements             -
                Population_Pyramid               -
                Questionnaire                    -
                Random_Sampling                  -
                Religion                         -
                Social_Facts                     -
                Social_Function                  -
                Social_Institutions              -
                Social_Network                   -
                Status_Set                       -
                Stereotype                       -
                Stigma                           -
                Subculture                       -
                Symbols                          -
                Tracking                         -
                Youth_Culture                    -

---

                Sociological_Normative_And_Value_Systems
                    Formal_Norms
                    Hidden_Curriculum
                    Ideal_Culture
                    Informal_Norms
                    Mores
                    Non-material_Culture
                    Norms
                    Real_Culture
                    Value_Neutrality
                    Values



                Class_System
                Colonialism
                Gender
                Gender_Order
                Gender_Relations
                Historical_And_Cultural_Context
                Holistic_Medicine
                Informal_Relations
                Informal_Social_Control
                Institutional_Discrimination
                Mass_Media
                Multimedia
                Negotiated_Order
                Network
                New_Social_Movements
                Population_Pyramid
                Questionnaire
                Random_Sampling
                Religion
                Social_Facts
                Social_Function
                Social_Institutions
                Social_Network
                Status_Set
                Stereotype
                Stigma
                Subculture
                Symbols
                Tracking
                Youth_Culture

============================================

Dear Gemini,

Many thanks, indeed... I successfully integrated the suggested
'Sociological_Normative_And_Value_Systems' intermediate superclass, as follows:

   1) Annotation of the newly defined intermediate superclass

           Sociological_Normative_And_Value_Systems = This sub-category encompasses the abstract and shared systems of rules, standards, expectations, and principles that guide collective behavior and shape moral judgments within a society. It includes both explicit, codified regulations and implicit cultural expectations, reflecting what is deemed desirable, appropriate, or important in various social contexts.

   2) Subclass relations

            Sociological_Normative_And_Value_Systems
                  ⊑ Sociological_Social_Structures_And_Institutions
                         ⊑ Sociological_Concepts_And_Theories (BFO_0000017 realizable entity)

   3) the 10 Subclasses of Sociological_Normative_And_Value_Systems

            Sociological_Normative_And_Value_Systems -
                Formal_Norms
                Hidden_Curriculum
                Ideal_Culture
                Informal_Norms
                Mores
                Non-material_Culture
                Norms
                Real_Culture
                Value_Neutrality
                Values

All of this can be easily followed in the three uploaded files.

The 'Sociological_Social_Structures_And_Institutions' superclass had 40 subclasses, but we have now moved 10 to the 'Sociological_Normative_And_Value_Systems' intermediate superclass... so there are 40 - 10 = 30 left, for which it would be worth defining some new intermediate superclasses.

I kindly ask you, dear Gemini, to take on this task.

A closer look: we have this class structure:

        Sociological_Concepts_And_Theories   BFO_0000017 realizable entity
            . . .
            Sociological_Social_Structures_And_Institutions  -
                Sociological_Political_Systems_And_Governance -
                    . . .
                Sociological_Family_And_Kinship_Systems  -
                    . . .
                Sociological_Normative_And_Value_Systems   -
                    . . .
             1) Class_System                     -
             2) Colonialism                      -
             3) Gender                           -
             4) Gender_Order                     -
             5) Gender_Relations                 -
             6) Historical_And_Cultural_Context  -
             7) Holistic_Medicine                -
             8) Informal_Relations               -
             9) Informal_Social_Control          -
            10) Institutional_Discrimination     -
            11) Mass_Media                       -
            12) Multimedia                       -
            13) Negotiated_Order                 -
            14) Network                          -
            15) New_Social_Movements             -
            16) Population_Pyramid               -
            17) Questionnaire                    -
            18) Random_Sampling                  -
            19) Religion                         -
            20) Social_Facts                     -
            21) Social_Function                  -
            22) Social_Institutions              -
            23) Social_Network                   -
            24) Status_Set                       -
            25) Stereotype                       -
            26) Stigma                           -
            27) Subculture                       -
            28) Symbols                          -
            29) Tracking                         -
            30) Youth_Culture                    -

So please, define intermediate superclasses to these numbered 30 subclasses, listed above...

=====================================================================
Gemini's answer:

Sociological_Social_Control_And_Collective_Action_Frameworks = This sub-category encompasses abstract concepts, strategies, and organizational forms related to how societies regulate behavior, maintain order, and respond to deviance, as well as how collective efforts are organized to achieve social goals or bring about change. It includes both formal and informal mechanisms of social control, and the frameworks of social movements and collective behavior.




    Sociology  BFO_0000001 entity
        . . .
        Sociological_Concepts_And_Theories   BFO_0000017 realizable entity
            . . .
            Sociological_Social_Structures_And_Institutions  -
                Sociological_Political_Systems_And_Governance -
                    . . .
                Sociological_Family_And_Kinship_Systems  -
                    . . .
                Sociological_Normative_And_Value_Systems   -
                    . . .
             1) Class_System                     -
             2) Colonialism                      -
             3) Gender                           -
             4) Gender_Order                     -
             5) Gender_Relations                 -
             6) Historical_And_Cultural_Context  -
             7) Holistic_Medicine                -
             8) Informal_Relations               -
             9) Informal_Social_Control          -
            10) Institutional_Discrimination     -
            11) Mass_Media                       -
            12) Multimedia                       -
            13) Negotiated_Order                 -
            14) Network                          -
            15) New_Social_Movements             -
            16) Population_Pyramid               -
            17) Questionnaire                    -
            18) Random_Sampling                  -
            19) Religion                         -
            20) Social_Facts                     -
            21) Social_Function                  -
            22) Social_Institutions              -
            23) Social_Network                   -
            24) Status_Set                       -
            25) Stereotype                       -
            26) Stigma                           -
            27) Subculture                       -
            28) Symbols                          -
            29) Tracking                         -
            30) Youth_Culture                    -

So please, define intermediate superclasses to these numbered 30 subclasses, listed above...


====================================================




Dear Gemini,

Thank you for your efforts once again, even though the results
seem to have been unexpected. I apologize if my request was not clearly worded.

My modest and humble request was actually to define intermediate superclasses
for the 30 numbered subclasses in the structure below:

    Sociology  BFO_0000001 entity
        . . .
        Sociological_Concepts_And_Theories   BFO_0000017 realizable entity
            . . .
            Sociological_Social_Structures_And_Institutions  -
                Sociological_Political_Systems_And_Governance -
                    . . .
                Sociological_Family_And_Kinship_Systems  -
                    . . .
                Sociological_Normative_And_Value_Systems   -
                    . . .
             1) Class_System                     -
             2) Colonialism                      -
             3) Gender                           -
             4) Gender_Order                     -
             5) Gender_Relations                 -
             6) Historical_And_Cultural_Context  -
             7) Holistic_Medicine                -
             8) Informal_Relations               -
             9) Informal_Social_Control          -
            10) Institutional_Discrimination     -
            11) Mass_Media                       -
            12) Multimedia                       -
            13) Negotiated_Order                 -
            14) Network                          -
            15) New_Social_Movements             -
            16) Population_Pyramid               -
            17) Questionnaire                    -
            18) Random_Sampling                  -
            19) Religion                         -
            20) Social_Facts                     -
            21) Social_Function                  -
            22) Social_Institutions              -
            23) Social_Network                   -
            24) Status_Set                       -
            25) Stereotype                       -
            26) Stigma                           -
            27) Subculture                       -
            28) Symbols                          -
            29) Tracking                         -
            30) Youth_Culture                    -

If I understand your suggestion correctly, you proposed the intermediate
superclass 'Sociological_Social_Control_And_Collective_Action_Frameworks'
for this purpose, whose parent would have been 'Sociological_Social_Structures_And_Institutions'.
I understand this, and I find it completely acceptable so far.

However, of the 11 subclasses proposed, only 4 come from the 30 classes listed:

        Colonialism
        Informal_Social_Control
        Institutional_Discrimination
        New_Social_Movements

The following statement is true for each of the 11-4=7 subclasses:

     [ Affirmative_Action,
       Apartheid,
       Formal_Social_Control,
       Law,
       Responses_To_Deviance,
       Social_Control,
       Social_Movement ]
           ⊑ Sociological_Political_Systems_And_Governance
               ⊑ Sociological_Social_Structures_And_Institutions
                   ⊑ Sociological_Concepts_And_Theories (BFO_0000017)
                       ⊑ Sociology (BFO_0000001)

In summary: of the 11 proposed subclasses, 7 have already been classified elsewhere.

May I ask whether I should create the proposed intermediate superclass called
'Sociological_Social_Control_And_Collective_Action_Frameworks,' with its 4 subclasses

        Colonialism
        Informal_Social_Control
        Institutional_Discrimination
        New_Social_Movements

and you will have further intermediate superclasses for the remaining 30 - 4 = 26 subclasses,
see below ?

      1)  Class_System
      2)  Gender
      3)  Gender_Order
      4)  Gender_Relations
      5)  Historical_And_Cultural_Context
      6)  Holistic_Medicine
      7)  Informal_Relations
      8)  Mass_Media
      9)  Multimedia
     10)  Negotiated_Order
     11)  Network
     12)  Population_Pyramid
     13)  Questionnaire
     14)  Random_Sampling
     15)  Religion
     16)  Social_Facts
     17)  Social_Function
     18)  Social_Institutions
     19)  Social_Network
     20)  Status_Set
     21)  Stereotype
     22)  Stigma
     23)  Subculture
     24)  Symbols
     25)  Tracking
     26)  Youth_Culture

Or would you like to start from scratch the previously defined task again, when you had
to define intermediate superclasses for 30 subclasses (see above) ?

Please advise and assist me, dear Gemini (oh yes... maybe your last answer was just a
momentary glissando... so let's not waste time on completely unnecessary excuses,
my dear helper, dear Gemini :)

============================================================ '

(1)  and (2)

Sociological_Social_Control_And_Collective_Action_Frameworks = This sub-category encompasses abstract concepts, strategies, and organizational forms related to how societies regulate behavior, maintain order, and respond to deviance, as well as how collective efforts are organized to achieve social goals or bring about change. It includes both formal and informal mechanisms of social control, and the frameworks of social movements and collective behavior.

Sociological_Classification_And_Categorization_Concepts = This sub-category groups abstract concepts, systems, and frameworks used by sociologists to understand how individuals and groups are categorized, ranked, and organized within social hierarchies. It includes concepts related to social class, status, and the underlying principles of social differentiation and stratification within societies.


                Sociological_Social_Control_And_Collective_Action_Frameworks
                    Colonialism
                    Informal_Social_Control
                    Institutional_Discrimination
                    New_Social_Movements
                Sociological_Classification_And_Categorization_Concepts
                    Class_System
                    Gender
                    Gender_Order
                    Gender_Relations
                    Status_Set
                    Stereotype
                    Stigma
                    Subculture
                    Youth_Culture
                Historical_And_Cultural_Context
                Holistic_Medicine
                Informal_Relations
                Mass_Media
                Multimedia
                Negotiated_Order
                Network
                Population_Pyramid
                Questionnaire
                Random_Sampling
                Religion
                Social_Facts
                Social_Function
                Social_Institutions
                Social_Network
                Symbols
                Tracking

-----
                Sociological_Social_Control_And_Collective_Action_Frameworks  -
                    Colonialism                                               -
                    Informal_Social_Control                                   -
                    Institutional_Discrimination                              -
                    New_Social_Movements                                      -
                Sociological_Classification_And_Categorization_Concepts      -
                    Class_System                                             -
                    Gender                                                   -
                    Gender_Order                                             -
                    Gender_Relations                                         -
                    Status_Set                                               -
                    Stereotype                                               -
                    Stigma                                                   -
                    Subculture                                               -
                    Youth_Culture                                            -
                Historical_And_Cultural_Context            -
                Holistic_Medicine                          -
                Informal_Relations                         -
                Mass_Media                                 -
                Multimedia                                 -
                Negotiated_Order                           -
                Network                                    -
                Population_Pyramid                         -
                Questionnaire                              -
                Random_Sampling                            -
                Religion                                   -
                Social_Facts                               -
                Social_Function                            -
                Social_Institutions                        -
                Social_Network                             -
                Symbols                                    -
                Tracking                                   -

============================================================

(2)

Sociological_Classification_And_Categorization_Concepts = This sub-category groups abstract concepts, systems, and frameworks used by sociologists to understand how individuals and groups are categorized, ranked, and organized within social hierarchies. It includes concepts related to social class, status, and the underlying principles of social differentiation and stratification within societies.

                Sociological_Classification_And_Categorization_Concepts
                    Class_System
                    Gender
                    Gender_Order
                    Gender_Relations
                    Status_Set
                    Stereotype
                    Stigma
                    Subculture
                    Youth_Culture
                Historical_And_Cultural_Context
                Holistic_Medicine
                Informal_Relations
                Mass_Media
                Multimedia
                Negotiated_Order
                Network
                Population_Pyramid
                Questionnaire
                Random_Sampling
                Religion
                Social_Facts
                Social_Function
                Social_Institutions
                Social_Network
                Symbols
                Tracking


----------------------


                Sociological_Classification_And_Categorization_Concepts      -
                    Class_System                                             -
                    Gender                                                   -
                    Gender_Order                                             -
                    Gender_Relations                                         -
                    Status_Set                                               -
                    Stereotype                                               -
                    Stigma                                                   -
                    Subculture                                               -
                    Youth_Culture                                            -
                Historical_And_Cultural_Context            -
                Holistic_Medicine                          -
                Informal_Relations                         -
                Mass_Media                                 -
                Multimedia                                 -
                Negotiated_Order                           -
                Network                                    -
                Population_Pyramid                         -
                Questionnaire                              -
                Random_Sampling                            -
                Religion                                   -
                Social_Facts                               -
                Social_Function                            -
                Social_Institutions                        -
                Social_Network                             -
                Symbols                                    -
                Tracking                                   -

======================================================

Dear Gemini,

Thank you very much, indeed... your proposals were excellent, perfect:
I implemented both of them. If I may add a few words about the suffixes of the
uploaded file names:


1) current BFO class mapping control file + yyyymmdd_hhmm time stamp

   BFO_ClassMapping_20250728_2311.txt


2) Protégé screenshot from the intermediate superclass
   'Sociological_Classification_And_Categorization_Concepts', and its
   subclasses. The suffix '__09' means the number of suggested subclasses

   Protege_20250728_2311__09.png


3) Protégé from the intermediate superclass
   'Sociological_Social_Control_And_Collective_Action_Frameworks', and its
   subclasses. The suffix '__04' means the number of suggested subclasses

   Protege_20250728_2311__04.png


4) Ontology Viewer screen shot from the intermediate superclass
   'Sociological_Classification_And_Categorization_Concepts', and its
   subclasses. The suffix '__09' means the number of suggested subclasses

   ontologyViewer_20250728_2311__09.png


5) Ontology Viewer rom the intermediate superclass
   'Sociological_Social_Control_And_Collective_Action_Frameworks', and its
   subclasses. The suffix '__04' means the number of suggested subclasses

   ontologyViewer_20250728_2311__04.png


Let me draw your attention to the arithmetic of the dwindling subclasses:
last time, there were 30 of them, from which 4 were first subtracted, then 9,
when we classified them under two intermediate superclasses.

So the number has dropped to 30 - 4 - 9 = 17.

With your permission, I will take care of the number of classes to be further classified :)

Please define additional intermediate superclasses for the 17 subclasses listed here (AND ONLY FOR THESE :)  These classes are direct sublasses yet of the
class' Sociological_Social_Structures_And_Institutions', and the follosing statement is true:

            Sociological_Social_Structures_And_Institutions
               ⊑ Sociological_Concepts_And_Theories (BFO_0000017)
                    ⊑ Sociology (BFO_0000001)

              1)  Historical_And_Cultural_Context
              2)  Holistic_Medicine
              3)  Informal_Relations
              4)  Mass_Media
              5)  Multimedia
              6)  Negotiated_Order
              7)  Network
              8)  Population_Pyramid
              9)  Questionnaire
             10)  Random_Sampling
             11)  Religion
             12)  Social_Facts
             13)  Social_Function
             14)  Social_Institutions
             15)  Social_Network
             16)  Symbols
             17)  Tracking

Thanks you very much, in advance as well...

=============================================================

Sociological_Fundamental_Social_Constructs = This sub-category encompasses core, abstract sociological concepts and frameworks that describe the fundamental nature, organization, and functioning of social reality and collective life. It includes the underlying principles, forms, and inherent characteristics of societies and their various components, as viewed from a sociological perspective.

Sociological_Social_Representations_And_Interactions = This sub-category groups abstract concepts and patterns related to how social reality is mediated, understood, and expressed, particularly concerning communication, social networks, and the forms of social categorization. It highlights the symbolic, interactive, and classificatory elements that shape social experience and relationships within society.


---------------------------------------------------




                |

                Sociological_Fundamental_Social_Constructs   -
                    Historical_And_Cultural_Context          -
                    Holistic_Medicine                        -
                    Negotiated_Order                         -
                    Religion                                 -
                    Social_Facts                             -
                    Social_Function                          -
                    Social_Institutions                      -
                Sociological_Social_Representations_And_Interactions    -
                    Informal_Relations                       -
                    Mass_Media                               -
                    Multimedia                               -
                    Network                                  -
                    Population_Pyramid                       -
                    Questionnaire                            -
                    Random_Sampling                          -
                    Social_Network                           -
                    Symbols                                  -
                    Tracking                                 -

--------------------------------------------------

                Sociological_Fundamental_Social_Constructs
                    Historical_And_Cultural_Context
                    Holistic_Medicine
                    Negotiated_Order
                    Religion
                    Social_Facts
                    Social_Function
                    Social_Institutions
                Sociological_Social_Representations_And_Interactions
                    Informal_Relations
                    Mass_Media
                    Multimedia
                    Network
                    Population_Pyramid
                    Questionnaire
                    Random_Sampling
                    Social_Network
                    Symbols
                    Tracking

=========================================================

Dear Gemini,

Thank you very much for your work and your comprehensive help.
With your permission, I have modified your suggestion slightly,
but I strongly believe that you will agree with all of this...

The 5 files uploaded show the actual implementation (let's ignore
the arithmetic of the number of subclasses again this time :)

Dear Gemini, may I ask you to further classify a few more classes
that have "too many" subclasses. First of all, within the BFO_0000017
realm, of course...

I have listed 5 of these candidates below:

    Sociology   BFO_0000001 entity

        Sociological_Concepts_And_Theories   BFO_0000017 realizable entity

            Sociological_Theoretical_Perspectives_And_Frameworks
                . . .  (REALM-A: 39 subclasses)

            Sociological_Research_Methods_And_Concepts
                . . .  (REALM-B: 33 subclasses)

            Sociological_Academic_Disciplines_And_Fields
                . . .  (REALM-C: 21 subclasses)

           Sociological_Social_Structures_And_Institutions
                Sociological_Political_Systems_And_Governance
                . . .  (REALM-D: 24 subclasses)

           Sociological_Social_Relationships_And_Organization
                . . .  (REALM-E: 25 subclasses)

Let me suggest starting with the first one right away.

        Sociological_Concepts_And_Theories   BFO_0000017 realizable entity
            Sociological_Theoretical_Perspectives_And_Frameworks
               1 Anomie_Theory_Of_Deviance
               2 Cognitive_Theory_Of_Development
               3 Conflict_Perspective
               4 Conflict_Theories
               5 Contact_Hypothesis
               6 Control_Theory
               7 Cornucopian_Theory
               8 Disengagement_Theory
               9 Elite_Model
              10 Evolutionary_Theory
              11 Exploitation_Theory
              12 Functionalism
              13 Functionalist_Perspective
              14 Grand_Theories
              15 Labeling_Theory
              16 Marxist_Theory
              17 Metanarratives
              18 Modernization_Theory
              19 Multilinear_Evolutionary_Theory
              20 Multiple-nuclei_Theory
              21 New_Urban_Sociology
              22 Pluralist_Model
              23 Positivism
              24 Postmodernism
              25 Poststructuralism
              26 Queer_Theory
              27 Routine_Activities_Theory
              28 Sapir-Whorf_Hypothesis
              29 Social_Constructionist_Perspective
              30 Social_Evolution
              31 Societal-reaction_Approach
              32 Sociobiology
              33 Sociological_Theory
              34 Structural_Functionalism
              35 Symbolic_Interactionism
              36 Theory
              37 Unilinear_Evolutionary_Theory
              38 World_Systems
              39 World_Systems_Analysis

Dear Gemini, I think I can save you a lot of work (and you can save me a
lot of work too, of course) if we pay close attention to the following rules:

1) You should only pay attention to the classes in the given domain. You have
accurate, precise knowledge of what their names mean... but I have also
uploaded once again the annotations of almost 600 classes into a single file:
'OWLclassAnnotations.txt' is the name of this the file, which contain the
class annotations.

2) So all that remains is the semantic analysis of the given domain,
to which the generation of the appropriate intermediate superclass
and its precise linguistic representation will follow: this should
hardly cause you any difficulty, dear Gemini, given your immeasurable
linguistic skills.

Well, I would venture to suggest the following steps...

Please further classify the intermediate superclasses (yes... I would
venture to entrust you with suggesting 6-7 intermediate superclasses
for the 39 classes in one step, or - as before - suggesting only one
intermediate superclass in one step).

Thanks you so much for your work...

====================================================

Dear Gemini,

Let us turn our attention to your last four proposals,
which would have involved further structuring of 39 subclasses.

Part 1)
Proposed new Parent: Sociological_Functionalist_Theories
                         ⊑ Sociological_Theoretical_Perspectives_And_Frameworks

Proposed direct subclasses:
   !!! Equilibrium_Model
       Functionalism
       Functionalist_Perspective
       Structural_Functionalism

Collision:  Equilibrium_Model
                ⊑ Sociological_Abstract_Social_Concepts
                   ⊑ Sociological_Concepts_And_Theories   BFO_0000017
                      ⊑ Sociology BFO_0000001

Part 2)
Proposed new Parent: Sociological_Conflict_Theories
                         ⊑ Sociological_Theoretical_Perspectives_And_Frameworks

Proposed direct subclasses:
    Conflict_Perspective
    Conflict_Theories
    Exploitation_Theory
    Marxist_Theory

Collision:  none

Part 3)
Proposed new Parent: Sociological_Interactionist_And_Interpretive_Theories
                         ⊑ Sociological_Theoretical_Perspectives_And_Frameworks

Proposed direct subclasses:
 !!! Dramaturgical_Analysis
 !!! Dramaturgical_Approach
 !!! Interpretative_Sociology
     Symbolic_Interactionism

Collisions: [ Dramaturgical_Analysis,
              Dramaturgical_Approach,
              Interpretative_Sociology ]
                  ⊑ Sociological_Research_Methods_And_Concepts
                     ⊑ Sociological_Concepts_And_Theories   BFO_0000017
                        ⊑ Sociology BFO_0000001

Part 4)
Proposed new Parent: Sociological_Evolutionary_And_Developmental_Theories
                         ⊑ Sociological_Theoretical_Perspectives_And_Frameworks

Proposed direct subclasses:
     Cognitive_Theory_Of_Development
     Evolutionary_Theory
     Multilinear_Evolutionary_Theory
     Social_Evolution
 !!! Sociocultural_Evolution
     Unilinear_Evolutionary_Theory

Collision:  Sociocultural_Evolution
                ⊑ Sociological_Social_Relationships_And_Organization
                    ⊑ Sociological_Concepts_And_Theories   BFO_0000017
                        ⊑ Sociology BFO_0000001

You would fundamentally misunderstand the above list, dear Gemini,
if you thought that I was in the slightest bit dissatisfied with
these four lists... no, not at all :)

My primary task is to make your work as easy and simple as possible.

My current proposal below serves this and only this purpose.
The proposal is not new, but rather a natural continuation of
the previous one. Its essence is as follows:

1) From now on, you no longer have to worry about which classes
should be further classified.

2) But now you no longer have to "keep in mind" the meaning of
the classes to be further classified (I think this was necessary
until now).

3) I would attach (with your permission) a text file to each request, the structure of which (since you are also familiar with the BNF notation) is as follows:

<textfile> ::= <lines> | <lines> <line>
          <line> ::= { classname } { " = " }  { class annotation... }

In which the 'classname' member of the lines will contain the names of the classes to be classified. A simple Java app is used to collect annotations for classes that need to be further classified. This also ensures that data preparation is accurate and free from human error.

4) Your very valuable and helpful work (in my opinion) would consist of the following:

4.1) You would read through this text file line by line, as many times as necessary.
        I think it would be a significant additional help if the class name were immediately followed by the class annotation,
        so that you would no longer need to search for the class annotations in a ~600-line, several 100 kB file,
        or, so to speak, "keep them in your head."

4.2)  You would then select a cohesive subset of class names and send these class names to me

4.3)  You would define an intermediate superclass above the selected class subset

4.4)  You would send me a normal-sized
         (a few hundred words) annotation for the intermediate superclass defined in this way.

5) I would immediately implement this new structure myself in the development
   pipeline (but would continue to check its consistency, with your permission

I believe, dear Gemini, that with this method, there would be significantly fewer,
or even zero, collisions in the classification of classes...

I would be honored if you would share your opinion on the proposal... If I may add... it would be worthwhile to at least try this method.

If you have a positive, accepting opinion, I will send you the first such file
right away :)

================================================================

Thank you so much for your valuable opinion, dear Gemini...

Just as an aside: with your permission, I would disregard your latter suggestion, as even that is riddled with conflicts (Questionnaire, Mass_Media, Network, etc.). So let's forget about it and I'll send the file right away :)

So the mentioned file,- its name is classesToBeFurtherClassified.txt.
The content of this files will change each time...

And at last the context, the structural place of these classes in the
file:

    [ * ] ⊑ Sociological_Theoretical_Perspectives_And_Frameworks
              ⊑ Sociological_Concepts_And_Theories BFO_0000017
                  ⊑ Sociology BFO_0000001

So please process these 39 classes, dear Geminni...

And let me draw your attention to the fact that from now on, you can only create further subgroups from this domain containing 39 classes :)

It would be perfectly sufficient if you could prepare a SINGLE COHESIVE SUBGROUP for me, dear Gemini... with the appropriate intermediate superclass and its annotation.

Needless to say, this number 39 will decrease in my next request by the number of classes contained in the subgroup you have created. But you don't have to worry about the arithmetic either: the Java tool mentioned above takes care of all that...

Thank you very much for your work :)


=====================================================

Dear Gemini,

I am so sorry... sending the single word "Modernization" was by no means
intentional (why? Because I'm using 11 open windows currently on an
Apple Pro Display XDR 32" screen :)

But let's not worry about that...

I regret to note that, despite my latest (and hardly simplifiable)
suggestion, you have managed to classify a class name
'Sociocultural_Evolution' that was already classified elsewhere.

As you wrote:

Proposed new Parent: Sociological_Theories_of_Social_Change_and_Evolution
                         ⊑ Sociological_Theoretical_Perspectives_And_Frameworks

Proposed direct subclasses:
        Evolutionary_Theory
        Modernization_Theory
        Multilinear_Evolutionary_Theory
        Social_Evolution
    !!! Sociocultural_Evolution
        Unilinear_Evolutionary_Theory

Collision:  Sociocultural_Evolution
               ⊑ Sociological_Social_Relationships_And_Organization
                   ⊑ Sociological_Concepts_And_Theories BFO_0000017
                         ⊑ Sociology BFO_0000001

If you agree, I would leave this structure in the implementation:

                Sociological_Theories_of_Social_Change_and_Evolution
                    Evolutionary_Theory
                    Modernization_Theory
                    Multilinear_Evolutionary_Theory
                    Social_Evolution
                    Unilinear_Evolutionary_Theory

As it can be shown on the uploaded screen shot file
'Sociological_Theories_of_Social_Change_and_Evolution.png'

Of course, I am persistent and will make use of all your valuable
suggestions (despite my some critical comments), dear Gemini...

And with that, the number of classes to be further classified in the
newly uploaded, actualized 'classesToBeFurtherClassified.txt' file has
already dropped to 39 - 5 = 34.

So please process these 34 classes, dear Geminni... and please,
please... be so kind as to choose from the 34 classes in the file :)

And let me draw your attention to the fact that from now on, you can
only create further subgroups from this domain containing 34 classes :)

It would be perfectly sufficient if you could prepare the NEXT SINGLE C
OHESIVE SUBGROUP for me, dear Gemini... with the appropriate intermediate
superclass and its annotation.

Thank you very much again . . .

======================================================================

Dear Gemini,

Thanks you so much: almost perfect,
7 - 1 = 6 classes are involved

                Sociological_Theories_of_Deviance_And_Control
                    Anomie_Theory_Of_Deviance
                    Control_Theory
                    Labeling_Theory
                    Routine_Activities_Theory
                    Social_Constructionist_Perspective
                    Societal-reaction_Approach

Collision (no problem: I've negligate it :)

       Differential_Association
           ⊑ Sociological_Abstract_Social_Concepts
               ⊑ Sociological_Concepts_And_Theories BFO_0000017
                   Sociology BFO_0000001

Implementation is successful: see the
Sociological_Theories_of_Deviance_And_Control.png screen shot.

And with that, the number of classes to be further classified in the
newly uploaded, actualized 'classesToBeFurtherClassified.txt' file has
already dropped to 34 - 6 = 28.


So please process these 28 classes, dear Geminni... and please,
please... be so kind as to choose from the 28 classes in the file :)

And let me draw your attention to the fact that from now on, you can
only create further subgroups from this domain containing 34 classes :)

It would be perfectly sufficient if you could prepare the NEXT SINGLE C
OHESIVE SUBGROUP for me, dear Gemini... with the appropriate intermediate
superclass and its annotation.

Thank you very much, indeed . . .
__________________________________________________

Remark:

You wrote:
"Remove Deviant_Subculture from the
Sociological_Theoretical_Perspectives_And_Frameworks hierarchy."

I could not do that, because

       Deviant_Subculture
            ⊑ Sociological_Social_Relationships_And_Organization
                  ⊑Sociological_Concepts_And_Theories   BFO_0000017
                        ⊑ Sociology BFO_0000001

and so the mentioned class Deviant_Subculture
is not part of the Sociological_Theoretical_Perspectives_And_Frameworks
hierarchy.
==============================================================

Dear Gemini,

Thank you so much: it's perfect, marvellous :)
3 classes are involved:

                Sociological_Postmodern_And_Critical_Theories -
                    Postmodernism                                  -
                    Poststructuralism                              -
                    Queer_Theory                                   -

Implementation is successful: see the
Sociological_Postmodern_And_Critical_Theories.png screen shot.

And with that, the number of classes to be further classified in the
newly uploaded, actualized 'classesToBeFurtherClassified.txt' file has
already dropped to 28 - 3 = 25.

So please process these 25 classes, dear Geminni... and please,
please... be so kind as to choose from the 25 classes in the file :)

And let me draw your attention to the fact that from now on, you can
only create further subgroups from this domain containing 34 classes :)

It would be perfectly sufficient if you could prepare the NEXT SINGLE
COHESIVE SUBGROUP for me, dear Gemini... with the appropriate intermediate
superclass and its annotation.

Thank you very much, indeed . . .

----------------

Remark:

And finally, I realized (?) how big a mistake I made when I didn't point out to you that here... now... there are NO so-called master files: everything changes with the creation of each new subdomain.... so

1)  the entire class structure
2)  the BFO mapping
3) and even the class annotations :)

However, I am very happy that there are only a few minor errors, which I can easily correct :)

===================================================


Dear Gemini,

Thank you so much: it's perfect, marvellous :)
5 classes are involved:

                Sociological_General_And_Foundational_Theories
                    Grand_Theories
                    Metanarratives
                    Positivism
                    Theory
                    Sociological_Theory

Implementation is successful: see the
Sociological_General_And_Foundational_Theories.png screen shot.

And with that, the number of classes to be further classified in the
newly uploaded, actualized 'classesToBeFurtherClassified.txt' file has
already dropped to 25 - 5 = 20.

So please process these 20 classes, dear Geminni... and please,
please... be so kind as to choose from the 20 classes in the file :)

And let me draw your attention to the fact that from now on, you can
only create further subgroups from this domain containing 20 classes :)

It would be perfectly sufficient if you could prepare the NEXT SINGLE
COHESIVE SUBGROUP for me, dear Gemini... with the appropriate intermediate
superclass and its annotation.

Thank you very much, indeed . . .

===================================================

Dear Gemini,

Thanks be to God, I saved all of my messages sending to you.

--------------------------------
1) The starting point: 39 classes

"Let me suggest starting with the first one right away..." - as I wrote...

        Sociological_Concepts_And_Theories   BFO_0000017 realizable entity
            Sociological_Theoretical_Perspectives_And_Frameworks
               1 Anomie_Theory_Of_Deviance
               2 Cognitive_Theory_Of_Development
               3 Conflict_Perspective
               4 Conflict_Theories
               5 Contact_Hypothesis
               6 Control_Theory
               7 Cornucopian_Theory
               8 Disengagement_Theory
               9 Elite_Model
              10 Evolutionary_Theory
              11 Exploitation_Theory
              12 Functionalism
              13 Functionalist_Perspective
              14 Grand_Theories
              15 Labeling_Theory
              16 Marxist_Theory
              17 Metanarratives
              18 Modernization_Theory
              19 Multilinear_Evolutionary_Theory
              20 Multiple-nuclei_Theory
              21 New_Urban_Sociology
              22 Pluralist_Model
              23 Positivism
              24 Postmodernism
              25 Poststructuralism
              26 Queer_Theory
              27 Routine_Activities_Theory
              28 Sapir-Whorf_Hypothesis
              29 Social_Constructionist_Perspective
              30 Social_Evolution
              31 Societal-reaction_Approach
              32 Sociobiology
              33 Sociological_Theory
              34 Structural_Functionalism
              35 Symbolic_Interactionism
              36 Theory
              37 Unilinear_Evolutionary_Theory
              38 World_Systems
              39 World_Systems_Analysis

2) After that came 5 classes: 39 - 5 = 34 remained

                Sociological_Theories_of_Social_Change_and_Evolution
                    Evolutionary_Theory
                    Modernization_Theory
                    Multilinear_Evolutionary_Theory
                    Social_Evolution
                    Unilinear_Evolutionary_Theory

3) After that came 6 classes: 34 - 6 = 28 remained

                Sociological_Theories_of_Deviance_And_Control
                    Anomie_Theory_Of_Deviance
                    Control_Theory
                    Labeling_Theory
                    Routine_Activities_Theory
                    Social_Constructionist_Perspective
                    Societal-reaction_Approach

4) After that came 3 classes: 28 - 3 = 25 remained

                Sociological_Postmodern_And_Critical_Theories -
                    Postmodernism                                  -
                    Poststructuralism                              -
                    Queer_Theory                                   -

5) After that came 5 classes: 25 - 5 = 20 remained

                Sociological_General_And_Foundational_Theories
                    Grand_Theories
                    Metanarratives
                    Positivism
                    Theory
                    Sociological_Theory

--------------------------------

You've seen that these last class have already been successfully integrated.
And now (repeatedly, once again) I am sending you a list with 20 classes,
together with their annotations: 'classesToBeFurtherClassified.txt'

Btw. the file named 'each_BFO_0000017_ classes.txt' contains all of the 265
pieces BFO_0000017 mapped classes... including their structure :)

In this [26-45] lines contain the 20 classes referred to in the
'classesToBeFurtherClassified.txt' file...

If you find, dear Gemini, that this statement is correct, then I'd like to
ask you to classify these 20 classes further, ... and please,
please... be so kind as to choose from the 20 classes in the file :)
containing 20 classes :)

It would be perfectly sufficient if you could prepare the NEXT SINGLE
COHESIVE SUBGROUP for me, dear Gemini... with the appropriate intermediate
superclass and its annotation.

Thank you very much again...

==================================================

Dear Gemini,

Um, I don't understand something, Dear Gemini.
As you wrote:

"Direct Subclasses (selected ONLY from your provided
classesToBeFurtherClassified.txt list of 20 classes
that fit this specific focus):

Argot
Bilingualism
Face-work
Language
Looking-glass_Self
Microsociology
Non-verbal_Communication
Role_Taking
Semiotics
Social_Interaction
Symbolic_Interactionism

This forms a cohesive group of 11 classes."

Actually, I would like to ask you: I would appreciate it
if you could check once again whether the intersection
of the two sets you specified is REALLY a single element
(namely, the class called 'Symbolic_Interactionism'),
as I see it, or whether I am too tired to work anymore.

Set-1 (see above the 11 classes)

Set-2 (see below the 20 classes)

Cognitive_Theory_Of_Development
Conflict_Perspective
Conflict_Theories
Contact_Hypothesis
Cornucopian_Theory
Disengagement_Theory
Elite_Model
Exploitation_Theory
Functionalism
Functionalist_Perspective
Marxist_Theory
Multiple-nuclei_Theory
New_Urban_Sociology
Pluralist_Model
Sapir-Whorf_Hypothesis
Sociobiology
Structural_Functionalism
Symbolic_Interactionism
World_Systems
World_Systems_Analysis

I think it would be worthwhile to perform this operation again
from the beginning, dear Gemini...

I am happy to send you the "focus" file, which contains 20 class
names with the corresponding annotations once again.
The file name is: classesToBeFurtherClassified.txt

Thank you very much for all your help, dear Gemini...

==========================================================

Dear Gemini,

Sociological_Social_Psychological_And_Interpretive_Theories = This sub-category encompasses theoretical frameworks that delve into the intricate relationship between individual agency and social structures, often focusing on micro-level social interactions, the formation of identity, and the subjective interpretation of meaning. These theories explore how individuals perceive, create, and are shaped by their social world, and how psychological processes intersect with broader sociological phenomena.


                Sociological_Social_Psychological_And_Interpretive_Theories


evaluating the answer of Gemini...

